Physical activity and mental health among trauma-affected refugees : associations, experiences, and intervention efficacy
Author: Nilsson, Henrik
Date: 2024-09-20
Location: Atrium, Nobels väg 12B, Karolinska Institutet, Solna
Time: 10.00
Department: Inst för klinisk neurovetenskap / Dept of Clinical Neuroscience
View/ Open:
Thesis (1.055Mb)
Abstract
Aims: The overall aim of this thesis was to increase the understanding of physical activity (PA) and its impact on mental health and wellbeing among trauma-affected refugees and asylum-seekers, and with a particular focus on posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as a prevalent disorder in this context. More specifically, we sought to investigate experiences and preferences of participation in PA and exercise-based treatments from a holistic and patientcentered perspective (study I), to examine the prevalence of different levels of PA and associations with PTSD symptom severity (study II), and to evaluate the efficacy of a multi-component and trauma-informed PA intervention on symptoms of PTSD, depression, anxiety, and subjective wellbeing (study III). In study III, we also examined adherence to the intervention, changes in levels of PA and sedentary time, and a follow-up of all outcomes after six months.
Methods: The thesis comprises three studies, I) an explorative qualitative study with focus group discussions (n=33), II) a cross-sectional survey study (n=455), and III) a randomized controlled trial (n=183). Study I and III were conducted at the Swedish Red Cross Treatment Center for persons affected by war and torture (RCC Malmö) and study II at three housing facilities for asylum-seekers across Sweden. The methods for analyzing the collected data were conventional qualitative content analysis in study I, prevalence estimates, analysis of variance, and multivariable logistic regression analysis in study II, and mixed-effects linear regression models in study III. Basic descriptive statistics were also employed in all studies to describe the participants. The development of the study III intervention model and design were a part of the overall project, conducted in parallel with study I and II, and partially informed by the results of these preceding studies before the onset of study III.
Results: The results of study I outline a detailed description of trauma-affected refugees’ subjective experiences and preferences of participation in PA and exercise treatments, pointing to a multitude of pathways towards improvements in both mental and physical health domains, increased self-empowerment, and improved social adjustment. Treatment characteristics were experienced as highly supportive and the treatment group settings as a vehicle for overcoming social fear and isolation. The analysis resulted in one overarching theme reflecting the participants’ overall experiences as a process and building resilience through relief and recovery.
In study II, we found that almost half of the participants did not meet the general recommendations for a sufficient level of PA and there were significant differences in PTSD symptom severity between the groups with different levels of PA. Sufficient PA was associated with less PTSD compared to both insufficient PA and inactive, while insufficient PA was also associated with less PTSD compared to inactive. The associations between PA and PTSD persisted when controlling for sex, age, and exposure to torture, and level of PA was found to provide a high explanatory function for the variance in PTSD symptom severity.
The results of study III revealed that the multi-component and trauma-informed PA intervention had a significant impact on all primary and secondary outcomes. The between group difference in PTSD symptom severity corresponded to a large effect size. The average decrease in PTSD was clinically significant, as was the decrease in depression and anxiety, and the increase in wellbeing. The change in level PA was also significant and corresponded to a move from below to above the cutoff for a sufficient level of PA. All positive effects at postintervention persisted, or even further improved, at the 6-month follow-up. The overall intervention model appeared to be well received and tolerated, as reflected by a high adherence and a low dropout rate, and where a higher adherence was also associated with a greater reduction in PTSD.
Conclusions: The overall results of this thesis add to the empirical evidence of PA as an important factor in PTSD and support an increased focus on PA and exercise in the context of forced migration and trauma-affected refugees’ health and wellbeing. Increased PA promotion is justified at multiple levels, in line with the general guidelines and health benefits as associated with regular PA and exercise, and as a viable treatment modality to alleviate PTSD symptom severity and associated distress, and to increase wellbeing.
Methods: The thesis comprises three studies, I) an explorative qualitative study with focus group discussions (n=33), II) a cross-sectional survey study (n=455), and III) a randomized controlled trial (n=183). Study I and III were conducted at the Swedish Red Cross Treatment Center for persons affected by war and torture (RCC Malmö) and study II at three housing facilities for asylum-seekers across Sweden. The methods for analyzing the collected data were conventional qualitative content analysis in study I, prevalence estimates, analysis of variance, and multivariable logistic regression analysis in study II, and mixed-effects linear regression models in study III. Basic descriptive statistics were also employed in all studies to describe the participants. The development of the study III intervention model and design were a part of the overall project, conducted in parallel with study I and II, and partially informed by the results of these preceding studies before the onset of study III.
Results: The results of study I outline a detailed description of trauma-affected refugees’ subjective experiences and preferences of participation in PA and exercise treatments, pointing to a multitude of pathways towards improvements in both mental and physical health domains, increased self-empowerment, and improved social adjustment. Treatment characteristics were experienced as highly supportive and the treatment group settings as a vehicle for overcoming social fear and isolation. The analysis resulted in one overarching theme reflecting the participants’ overall experiences as a process and building resilience through relief and recovery.
In study II, we found that almost half of the participants did not meet the general recommendations for a sufficient level of PA and there were significant differences in PTSD symptom severity between the groups with different levels of PA. Sufficient PA was associated with less PTSD compared to both insufficient PA and inactive, while insufficient PA was also associated with less PTSD compared to inactive. The associations between PA and PTSD persisted when controlling for sex, age, and exposure to torture, and level of PA was found to provide a high explanatory function for the variance in PTSD symptom severity.
The results of study III revealed that the multi-component and trauma-informed PA intervention had a significant impact on all primary and secondary outcomes. The between group difference in PTSD symptom severity corresponded to a large effect size. The average decrease in PTSD was clinically significant, as was the decrease in depression and anxiety, and the increase in wellbeing. The change in level PA was also significant and corresponded to a move from below to above the cutoff for a sufficient level of PA. All positive effects at postintervention persisted, or even further improved, at the 6-month follow-up. The overall intervention model appeared to be well received and tolerated, as reflected by a high adherence and a low dropout rate, and where a higher adherence was also associated with a greater reduction in PTSD.
Conclusions: The overall results of this thesis add to the empirical evidence of PA as an important factor in PTSD and support an increased focus on PA and exercise in the context of forced migration and trauma-affected refugees’ health and wellbeing. Increased PA promotion is justified at multiple levels, in line with the general guidelines and health benefits as associated with regular PA and exercise, and as a viable treatment modality to alleviate PTSD symptom severity and associated distress, and to increase wellbeing.
List of papers:
I. Nilsson, H, Saboonchi, F, Gustavsson, C, Malm, A, Gottvall, M. (2019). Trauma-afflicted refugees’ experiences of participating in physical activity and exercise treatment: a qualitative study based on focus group discussions. European Journal of Psychotraumatology. 2019; 10(1): 1699327.
Fulltext (DOI)
Pubmed
View record in Web of Science®
II. Nilsson, H., Gustavsson, C., Gottvall, M., Saboonchi, F. (2021). Physical activity, post-traumatic stress disorder, and exposure to torture among asylum seekers in Sweden: a cross-sectional study. BMC Psychiatry. 2021; 21(1): 452.
Fulltext (DOI)
Pubmed
View record in Web of Science®
III. Nilsson, H., Gottvall, M., Gustavsson, C., Nissen, A., Saboonchi, F. Evaluation of a trauma-informed physical activity intervention for posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, and wellbeing in trauma-affected refugees: a randomized controlled trial. [Submitted]
I. Nilsson, H, Saboonchi, F, Gustavsson, C, Malm, A, Gottvall, M. (2019). Trauma-afflicted refugees’ experiences of participating in physical activity and exercise treatment: a qualitative study based on focus group discussions. European Journal of Psychotraumatology. 2019; 10(1): 1699327.
Fulltext (DOI)
Pubmed
View record in Web of Science®
II. Nilsson, H., Gustavsson, C., Gottvall, M., Saboonchi, F. (2021). Physical activity, post-traumatic stress disorder, and exposure to torture among asylum seekers in Sweden: a cross-sectional study. BMC Psychiatry. 2021; 21(1): 452.
Fulltext (DOI)
Pubmed
View record in Web of Science®
III. Nilsson, H., Gottvall, M., Gustavsson, C., Nissen, A., Saboonchi, F. Evaluation of a trauma-informed physical activity intervention for posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, and wellbeing in trauma-affected refugees: a randomized controlled trial. [Submitted]
Institution: Karolinska Institutet
Supervisor: Saboonchi, Fredrik
Co-supervisor: Gottvall, Maria; Gustavsson, Catharina
Issue date: 2024-08-27
Rights:
Publication year: 2024
ISBN: 978-91-8017-718-4
Statistics
Total Visits
Views | |
---|---|
Physical ... | 116 |
Total Visits Per Month
March 2024 | April 2024 | May 2024 | June 2024 | July 2024 | August 2024 | September 2024 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Physical ... | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 68 | 48 |
File Visits
Views | |
---|---|
Thesis_Henrik_Nilsson.pdf | 121 |
Top country views
Views | |
---|---|
Sweden | 34 |
China | 26 |
United States | 19 |
Ireland | 13 |
Australia | 2 |
Germany | 2 |
Philippines | 2 |
Åland Islands | 1 |
Bulgaria | 1 |
Finland | 1 |
Top cities views
Views | |
---|---|
Stockholm | 7 |
Norrköping | 6 |
Zhengzhou | 6 |
Dublin | 5 |
Corrandulla | 4 |
Shenzhen | 4 |
Hangzhou | 2 |
Hedemora | 2 |
Ashburn | 1 |
Borås | 1 |